I Do Not Have a Gentle Heart: Some Thoughts on Women in A Song of Ice and Fire

-
In case you don't read my main blog, let me tell you that I'm a huge fan of the A Song of Ice and Fire series and the Game of Thrones TV series. One of the reasons I like it so much, is that the characters are so realistic and well rounded, especially the female characters.

So often in fantasy novels that take place in a medieval world, the female characters take one of three forms: the tough but noble  do-gooder, the evil queen, and the locked in a tower princess. I think this is partly because  medieval writers had an extremely limited vocabulary when describing women, so fantasy writers who look back to that time period think that only two types of women existed in the medieval age: the paragon of virtue and the disgrace to the human race. What's so often ignored is that no one individual embodies any one of these archetypes. Real people aren't just evil queens or damsels in distress; they're a mixture of both.

And no character exemplifies that principle more than Dany Targaryen. Her unofficial motto, on the TV show anyway, has sort of become I Do Not Have a Gentle Heart. I think that's a really telling statement because it's so contradictory. I mean, she's not only talking about herself as a person, she's describing herself as a leader. And those two personas, I think we all can agree, are very different. 

I mean, as a person, she's extremely empathetic. She feels injustice very keenly. I mean, she spends most of the third and fifth books trying to free slaves and right wrongs, not the most politically expedient path for someone who's trying to win back a kingdom. I think it's very telling that her people identify her as a mother first and a ruler second. In fact, the reader is first introduced to the idea of Dany as a mother in book one; she is the Mother of Dragons. 

It's the 'of Dragons' part that really makes that statement really interesting. Maybe a mother has a gentle heart, but a mother of dragons? Not so much. Dany is a kind, compassionate person, but as a leader, she's tough and even ruthless. She's a dragon. This is what makes Dany so interesting, her mercy is exceeded only by her vengeance. Does that make her a virtuous or evil queen in themedieval  stereotype? Neither; it makes her an individual.

That's what's great about A Song of Ice and Fire, no one is reduced to an stereotype. Even Cersei, who is practically the definition of an evil queen has depth and complexity. I mean, so what if Dany does not have a gentle heart there's nothing wrong with that. She's Stormborn, the blood of dragons, wearing her heart on her sleeve wouldn't suit her anyway.

Just readin'

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Spiderman is in The Great Gatsby

-
Image
So, today I saw the new The Great Gatsby movie, to which I say "eh". I love the novel, but the movie version of The Great Gatsby sort of disappointed me. Sure, the movie was really cool from a visual standpoint, but it wasn't The Great Gatsby as it was written. They really took the substance out of the story and made it one long frat party, set to hip-hop music. Which didn't make a lot of sense to me, given that The Great Gatsby is supposed to be set in the 1920s. Apparently, no one told Baz Luhrmann. The problem with his adaptation is that Luhrmann was so heavy handed with the story. I mean, if the metaphors were any more obvious, they would jump out of the screen and beat you over the head with a herring. However, all those things are forgivable. What was not forgivable was the casting of Tobey Maguire as Nick Carraway. I say that not because his acting was bad, but because there is no place for Spider-Man in The Great Gatsby. Seriously, that was practicall
Read more

Noa Noa: Paul Gauguin & Romanticism

-
Image
Paul Gauguin is one of my favorite painters. (Actually, as I write this, there is a print of his painting  Mahana No Atua hanging next to me on my bedroom wall.) So, during my winter break, I decided to read his Tahitian journal, Noa Noa . Noa Noa is a travelogue written by Gauguin, first published in 1901. Although, Gauguin billed the book as his genuine experiences, it seems pretty clear to me and other critics that it's mostly fictional or exaggerated. That being said, I found the book to be very interesting. From a narrative perspective, Noa Noa is a bit dull. Gauguin's writing style has a tendency to be wordy and pedantic. However, from an ideological perspective it's quite interesting. To my mind, Gauguin is an excellent example of Romanticism and Romantic thought. If you don't know, Romanticism was an artistic and ideological movement that reacted against the Enlightenment. Romantics believed that the world could not be understood purely though the lens
Read more

The Best Viking Novels

-
Image
I don't know about you, but I love a good viking novel. I've been interested in history since I was a kid, and I've always been fascinated by the vikings. There's something about the stories of dragon ships and adventures on the sea that capture the imagination.  And, I'm certainly not the only person who thinks that way because there are a lot of books about vikings on the market. Of course, there are plenty of non-fiction books out there, and I've read (or listened to; I love audiobooks) to a couple of them, but novels about vikings seem to be much more popular. That being said, not all novels are equal. Personally, I prefer viking novels that encompass the perfect amount of adventure, drama, and (sometimes) romance.  Since I've been home a lot recently, I've been reading/listening (I love audiobooks) to some old favorites and to some new novels as well. So, today, I want to share some of my favorite viking novels (in no particular order) with you. Ha
Read more